Quality Research
Quality Research by Oleh Ivchenko · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19434311 86stabilfr·wuedophcgmx
| Badge | Metric | Value | Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [s] | Reviewed Sources | 64% | ○ | ≥80% from editorially reviewed sources |
| [t] | Trusted | 84% | ✓ | ≥80% from verified, high-quality sources |
| [a] | DOI | 72% | ○ | ≥80% have a Digital Object Identifier |
| [b] | CrossRef | 68% | ○ | ≥80% indexed in CrossRef |
| [i] | Indexed | 76% | ○ | ≥80% have metadata indexed |
| [l] | Academic | 72% | ○ | ≥80% from journals/conferences/preprints |
| [f] | Free Access | 96% | ✓ | ≥80% are freely accessible |
| [r] | References | 25 refs | ✓ | Minimum 10 references required |
| [w] | Words [REQ] | 2,600 | ✓ | Minimum 1,000 words of article body. Current: 2,600 |
| [u] | Original [REQ] | 100% | ✓ | ≥85% unique sentences (no padding or repeated blocks) and no leaked drafting notes. Current: 100% unique |
| [e] | Evidence [REQ] | 17 | ✓ | Cites at least 1 external source(s): links, DOIs or a reference list. Current: 17 |
| [d] | DOI [REQ] | ✓ | ✓ | Zenodo DOI registered for persistent citation. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19434311 |
| [o] | ORCID | ✓ | ✓ | Author ORCID verified for academic identity |
| [p] | Peer Reviewed | — | ○ | Peer reviewed by an assigned reviewer |
| [h] | Freshness | 65% | ✓ | ≥60% of references from 2025–2026. Current: 65% |
| [c] | Data Charts | 4 | ✓ | Original data charts from reproducible analysis (min 2). Current: 4 |
| [g] | Code | ✓ | ✓ | Source code available on GitHub |
| [m] | Diagrams | 3 | ✓ | Mermaid architecture/flow diagrams. Current: 3 |
| [x] | Cited by | 0 | ○ | Referenced by 0 other hub article(s) |
Score = Ref Trust (81 × 60%) + Required (4/4 × 30%) + Optional (5/7 × 10%)
The credibility of research platforms depends not only on the quality of individual publications but on systematic, measurable signals that allow readers, institutions, and policymakers to calibrate trust. This article examines how multi-dimensional badge scoring systems — exemplified by the STABIL framework — translate article-level quality evidence into platform-level credibility, and how com...
Show moreHideQuality Research by Oleh Ivchenko DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19434311 86stabilfr·wuedophcgmx
Article Quality Sc…Read More| Badge | Metric | Value | Status | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [s] | Reviewed Sources | 64% | ○ | ≥80% from editorially reviewed sources |
| [t] | Trusted | 84% | ✓ | ≥80% from verified, high-quality sources |
| [a] | DOI | 72% | ○ | ≥80% have a Digital Object Identifier |
| [b] | CrossRef | 68% | ○ | ≥80% indexed in CrossRef |
| [i] | Indexed | 76% | ○ | ≥80% have metadata indexed |
| [l] | Academic | 72% | ○ | ≥80% from journals/conferences/preprints |
| [f] | Free Access | 96% | ✓ | ≥80% are freely accessible |
| [r] | References | 25 refs | ✓ | Minimum 10 references required |
| [w] | Words [REQ] | 2,600 | ✓ | Minimum 1,000 words of article body. Current: 2,600 |
| [u] | Original [REQ] | 100% | ✓ | ≥85% unique sentences (no padding or repeated blocks) and no leaked drafting notes. Current: 100% unique |
| [e] | Evidence [REQ] | 17 | ✓ | Cites at least 1 external source(s): links, DOIs or a reference list. Current: 17 |
| [d] | DOI [REQ] | ✓ | ✓ | Zenodo DOI registered for persistent citation. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19434311 |
| [o] | ORCID | ✓ | ✓ | Author ORCID verified for academic identity |
| [p] | Peer Reviewed | — | ○ | Peer reviewed by an assigned reviewer |
| [h] | Freshness | 65% | ✓ | ≥60% of references from 2025–2026. Current: 65% |
| [c] | Data Charts | 4 | ✓ | Original data charts from reproducible analysis (min 2). Current: 4 |
| [g] | Code | ✓ | ✓ | Source code available on GitHub |
| [m] | Diagrams | 3 | ✓ | Mermaid architecture/flow diagrams. Current: 3 |
| [x] | Cited by | 0 | ○ | Referenced by 0 other hub article(s) |
Score = Ref Trust (81 × 60%) + Required (4/4 × 30%) + Optional (5/7 × 10%)